Mock up suggestions......

HomeBuiltAirplanes.com

Help Support HomeBuiltAirplanes.com:

MadProfessor8138

Well-Known Member
Log Member
Joined
Nov 3, 2015
Messages
851
Location
Ekron,Kentucky
So I'm thinking of mocking up an airframe that I've been designing and thought I would ask for opinions.
The real airframe will eventually be constructed of 4130 tubing with an aluminum tailboom.
I've thought of 2 different approaches to mock up a full scale airframe.

1. Wood :
A. Wooden dowels glued up in place of the 4130 tubing.
B. 5"-6" pvc pipe for the aluminum tailboom.

2. EMT....electrical metal tubing :
A. EMT brazed in place of the 4130 tubing.
B. 5"-6" pvc pipe for the aluminum tsilboom.

Should I go wooden dowel or EMT ?

Kevin
 

Victor Bravo

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 30, 2014
Messages
7,484
Location
KWHP, Los Angeles CA, USA
I vote for dowels. Slightly more expensive than EMT, but a lot lighter (to move the mock-up around the shop, hang it from the wall, etc.), PLUS you can glue it with CA or hot glue to make faster progress. Also a lot easier on the hole saw blades you will use to cope the joints.
 

MadProfessor8138

Well-Known Member
Log Member
Joined
Nov 3, 2015
Messages
851
Location
Ekron,Kentucky
I'm kinda leaning towards the wooden dowels too....I'm currently building a wooden aircraft and to be honest,i just like working with wood.

Two issues that I'm concerned about though.......

1. The airframe has some curves and the dowels will need to be bent.
I'm currently researching whether or not dowels can be bent with steam or ammonia.

2. I actually plan to build a full scale airframe to sit in so I can adjust measurements here and there.
Not sure if the dowels will be strong enough for this.

Kevin
 

akwrencher

Well-Known Member
HBA Supporter
Joined
Oct 16, 2012
Messages
1,219
Location
Gustavus, AK
I'm kinda leaning towards the wooden dowels too....I'm currently building a wooden aircraft and to be honest,i just like working with wood.

Two issues that I'm concerned about though.......

1. The airframe has some curves and the dowels will need to be bent.
I'm currently researching whether or not dowels can be bent with steam or ammonia.

2. I actually plan to build a full scale airframe to sit in so I can adjust measurements here and there.
Not sure if the dowels will be strong enough for this.

Kevin
On the plus side for wood, steaming isn't very hard, or try some fabric softenrr. My late uncle used it many years ago to soften an oil frame for his boat that was giving him trouble. I like the idea of the emt myself though. It wouldn't be terribly hard to tack weld it together with a wire feed. I don't see why you would need to cope the ends for a mock up. No flight loads. Downside is it's probably galvanized, which sucks to weld. Not good for the old lungs.
 

pictsidhe

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 15, 2014
Messages
7,558
Location
North Carolina
Wood is good!

Pvc pipe is light, glueable, bendable with heat. Could also be pop rivetted with gussets.

The EMT I've seen here ia galvanised. That isn't much fun to weld.
 

Bill-Higdon

Well-Known Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2011
Messages
636
Location
Salem, Oregon, USA
So I'm thinking of mocking up an airframe that I've been designing and thought I would ask for opinions.
The real airframe will eventually be constructed of 4130 tubing with an aluminum tailboom.
I've thought of 2 different approaches to mock up a full scale airframe.

1. Wood :
A. Wooden dowels glued up in place of the 4130 tubing.
B. 5"-6" pvc pipe for the aluminum tailboom.

2. EMT....electrical metal tubing :
A. EMT brazed in place of the 4130 tubing.
B. 5"-6" pvc pipe for the aluminum tsilboom.

Should I go wooden dowel or EMT ?

Kevin
Down side to PVC is it's flexibility, something the FMX-1 Group learned the hard way, it was ok for a first quick & dirty check but that's about it
 

TFF

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 28, 2010
Messages
13,078
Location
Memphis, TN
PVC. Coping the joints and gluing will get you just about the same experience as 4130 and all sorts of sizes. Long too. It will be cheaper too. Dowels, I hate the wood they use for hardware store dowels. They are not straight. They are some type of foreign junk wood. I look at them for RC projects all the time and pass.

Wood is normally my go to for mocking something. I think The PVC will work through the problems better and will be easier to scrap without feeling bad. You don’t want to be attached to the mock up.
 

TFF

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 28, 2010
Messages
13,078
Location
Memphis, TN
On the bending of 4130 airframe parts, how much bending are you wanting? Anything fancy will need a mandrel bender. Anything tighter than Cub tail parts will kink up.
 

MadProfessor8138

Well-Known Member
Log Member
Joined
Nov 3, 2015
Messages
851
Location
Ekron,Kentucky
Everyone is bringing up some good points and I appreciate the input.
I see pros and cons with each material that could be used for the mock up...

PVC......
Pro :
1. readily available
2. fairly cheap
3. easy to work with
Con :
1. Flexibility
2. pieces tend to not be straight...memory from being stacked in a pile

EMT.....
Pro :
1. readily available
2. fairly cheap
3. can be drilled for bolts and rivets
4. can be bent fairly easily
5. can be welded or brazed
6. Light weight
Con :
1. precautions must be taken if welded or brazed because its galvanized....not difficult to do,just an extra step

Dowel.....
Pro :
1. I like working with wood
Con :
1. material will have to be ordered in for the lengths desired...not much available locally
2. they tend to not be straight
3. can be expensive if not careful
4. any bending may turn out to be problematic

After searching through past threads I ran across a mock up that Toobuilder had done with EMT....he had some nice results.
After looking at the pros and cons list....the EMT seems to be the better choice of the materials.

Kevin
 

Hot Wings

Grumpy Cynic
HBA Supporter
Log Member
Joined
Nov 14, 2009
Messages
7,085
Location
Rocky Mountains
EMT.....
<< >>
Con :
1. precautions must be taken if welded or brazed because its galvanized....not difficult to do,just an extra step
A soak in muratic acid, picked up at the hardware store with the EMT along with a length of plastic gutter and ends (for the soaking trough), takes care of the zinc.
 

MadProfessor8138

Well-Known Member
Log Member
Joined
Nov 3, 2015
Messages
851
Location
Ekron,Kentucky
Victor Bravo.........I'm reluctant to post anything on the forum pertaining to the 2 designs that I'm working on....sadly.
Each one of the designs has a few issues that I'm still trying to find the answers to....no design is strictly straightforward,there are always complications.
I posted in the past hoping to receive some helpful suggestions and input from everyone but it quickly turned into a discussion ranging from ....you aren't a BIG name in aerospace so you can't possibly design anything....you're going to kill yourself....if you dont use carbon fiber and unobtainium costing $millions$ then it will never be airworthy.....etc,etc,etc.
I would truly LOVE to post my ideas because I know there are individuals on here that could easily answer questions to a few areas that I'm having problems with....but being a public forum,you tend to get overwhelmed with all of the naysayers derailing the thread and trashing it up instead of actually contributing useful information.

Kevin
 

MadProfessor8138

Well-Known Member
Log Member
Joined
Nov 3, 2015
Messages
851
Location
Ekron,Kentucky
You know what....I'm going to post a tad bit of info anyways.
You guys have tried to help with suggestions for a mock up and deserve to know what I'm working on.
I wont post any of my design sketches right now but this will give you an idea of what I'm designing...

Design 1.....A10 Warthog
ffd2011_a10_5961587133.jpg

Design 2....Ultrabat
images.jpeg.jpg
maxresdefault.jpg

This is a new rendition of an old design...

Kevin
 

Hephaestus

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jun 25, 2014
Messages
1,756
Location
YMM
Since it's mock-up and you'll be tweaking.

I vote emt and plumbing strapping/self drilling screws. That way you can take it apart and refit / adjust easily as you go and find issues to resolve.
 

wb2754

Member
Joined
Jun 5, 2016
Messages
22
Location
NW Fl
If you have a router, you can make round dowels whatever length you need.
3/4 in. sq wood would work well.
Maybe a little biased....building an all wood LSA Maranda.
 
Top