# Cargo plane approach to the flying car

Discussion in 'Aircraft Design / Aerodynamics / New Technology' started by cluttonfred, Mar 8, 2013.

1. Mar 8, 2013

### cluttonfred

#### Well-Known Member

Joined:
Feb 13, 2010
Messages:
6,351
2,208
Location:
World traveler
The late French designer Marcel Jurca is best know for his aerobatic sportplanes and replica WWII warbirds, but he also designed this odd little beastie, the MJ.54 Silas (also called Tegas, not sure why) a spacious four-seater with a rear loading ramp capable of carrying a two people and tiny microcar.

Now that category of "car without a license" is essentially a four-wheeled moped with a top speed under 30 mph which weights under 900 lbs with a full fuel tank and about 300 mile range. Such cars don't exist in the USA and the low-speed electric vehicles that fulfill a similar role are much heaver. And I will readily admit that the MJ.54 is an uncharasterically hideous plane from the pen of same man who designed the MJ.2 Tempete and many other lovely designs. But the concept seems sound.

I have seen schemes for transporting motorcycles in belly pods on both experimental and certified planes, but what about designing a homebuilt plane to carry your ground transportation from the get go. I could a design in the spirty of the MJ.54 able to fold up all but the pilot and front passenger seats and carry your ground transport as cargo instead. A four-seater could give up two seats for 500 lbs of cargo, which won't get you a car but will get you a couple of mopeds or scooters or a modest two-passenger scooter or motorcycle and some baggage. A six-seater could give up four seats and carry as much as 1,000 lbs of cargo which would get you one cruising motorcycle, two modest motorcycles maybe one of the great Russian Ural or Indian Enfield motorcycles with sidecars. Of course, electric vehicles would be even better -- no fuel to worry about -- if they are light enough.

What does everyone thing? What are some ways to tackle such a miniature cargo plane to bring along your own ground transportation? Here are a few images to provide some food for thought:

Cheers,

Matthew

File size:
54.1 KB
Views:
865
File size:
26.8 KB
Views:
533
File size:
227.7 KB
Views:
593
File size:
32.8 KB
Views:
830
2. Mar 8, 2013

### ultralajt

#### Well-Known Member

Joined:
May 10, 2009
Messages:
1,559
743
Location:
Slovenia
Topspeed.. sorry.. Matthew, you never get out of ideas about new interesting odd plane layout?

3. Mar 8, 2013

### Jay Kempf

#### Well-Known Member

Joined:
Apr 13, 2009
Messages:
3,531
865
Location:
Warren, VT USA

Wow. Thanks for sharing that one. I have personally never seen a picture or heard of that plane. Really nice idea in terms of unlimited travel. ​

4. Mar 8, 2013

### cluttonfred

#### Well-Known Member

Joined:
Feb 13, 2010
Messages:
6,351
2,208
Location:
World traveler
The point was not the layout but the mission--how would you carry 4-6 people or, alternatively, two people and their ground transportation?

5. Mar 8, 2013

### Dana

#### Moderator

Joined:
Apr 4, 2007
Messages:
8,454
2,853
Location:
CT, USA
On a somewhat larger note, the Short Skyvan was specifically to carry vehicles of the VW Microbus size...

-Dana

We are sorry, you have reached an imaginary number.

6. Mar 8, 2013

#### Moderator

Joined:
Jul 8, 2009
Messages:
10,738
2,537
Location:
Rotterdam, Netherlands
The Tata Nano, Lotus Elise and Smart come to mind as some of the lightest production cars. All of them are 600+ kg's, so simply far too heavy for any affordable aircraft.

That IMHO only leaves motorbikes. A basic 600 cc bike is far less than 200 kg and within the realm of an affordable plane. There was an (Italian, recent?) aircraft with double fins and a rear door that was close to ideal for a motorbike in the rear.

7. Mar 9, 2013

### thump

#### Well-Known Member

Joined:
Feb 12, 2011
Messages:
113
40
Location:
idaho
Last edited: Mar 9, 2013
8. Mar 9, 2013

### cluttonfred

#### Well-Known Member

Joined:
Feb 13, 2010
Messages:
6,351
2,208
Location:
World traveler
Three-wheel vehicles offer an interesting compromise that might be useful for this application, from kits like the Pembleton Grasshopper to the new one from Elio Motors, a start-up company setting up production in an old GM plant in Louisiana. The interesting point for this discussion is that many of three-wheelers weigh substantially under 1,000 pounds--the Pembleton, for example, can be built under 700 pounds.

Sockmonkey likes this.
9. Mar 9, 2013

#### Moderator

Joined:
Jul 8, 2009
Messages:
10,738
2,537
Location:
Rotterdam, Netherlands
In that case, I'd design one myself. Something like the Acabion:

But then redesigned for low weight, small dimensions and reasonable power.

Last edited by a moderator: Mar 20, 2019
10. Mar 9, 2013

### henryk

#### Well-Known Member

Joined:
Mar 8, 2010
Messages:
4,544
417
Location:
krakow,poland
Last edited: Mar 9, 2013
11. Mar 9, 2013

### jedi

#### Well-Known Member

Joined:
Aug 8, 2009
Messages:
1,681
374
Location:
Sahuarita Arizona, Renton Washington, USA
I will say again, why would anybody want to go 300 mph on the ground? At that speed you can fly and do not have to worry about hitting things.

12. Mar 9, 2013

### cluttonfred

#### Well-Known Member

Joined:
Feb 13, 2010
Messages:
6,351
2,208
Location:
World traveler
The first two links didn't work for me, but other than some light tanks parachuted from cargo planes or literally dropped off the ramp of cargo planes at low altitude, the only system that I am aware of ever being used in combat is the Hamilcar glider with the tank INSIDE the fuselage as cargo.

13. Mar 14, 2013

### bmcj

#### Well-Known MemberHBA Supporter

Joined:
Apr 10, 2007
Messages:
12,557
4,580
Location:
Fresno, California
Except maybe UAV drones.

14. Mar 14, 2013

### oriol

#### Well-Known Member

Joined:
Dec 31, 2009
Messages:
769
134
Location:
Barcelona, Spain.
The cargo plane for small vehicles approach reminds a lot to WWII cargo gliders, as from what I red about them It was imposible to fly those gliders empty, with no ballast.
Maybe a two floor solution, something like the old Sikorsky S55 helicopter, can work to solve the center and ballance issue.

As AR allready pointed out, even an average "small" car seems too heavy to result in an affordable airplane.

Oriol

Last edited: Mar 14, 2013
15. Mar 14, 2013

### psween

#### Well-Known Member

Joined:
Jan 20, 2011
Messages:
100
20
Location:
7MN3
Wasn't Dean Wilson's Global Explorer originally intended to carry a broken down Robinson R22 in the back? Seem to remember reading that some where. If so, substitute a couple of motorcycles or a small two seat car and you might be there.

Patrick

16. Mar 15, 2013

### PTAirco

#### Well-Known Member

Joined:
Sep 21, 2003
Messages:
3,412
953
Location:
Corona CA
I read it was an Avid Flyer, with its wings folded.

Perhaps one approach would be to integrate both airframe and car design, so one fits into the other perfectly with no compromises. I kind of package deal. I certainly believe you can make a purpose designed two seat car under 600lbs or so.

17. Mar 16, 2013

### cluttonfred

#### Well-Known Member

Joined:
Feb 13, 2010
Messages:
6,351
2,208
Location:
World traveler
How about the 200 lb, two-seat Peel Trident? It's really just an enclosed electric scooter, but its road-legal in the UK and USA and will go 80 miles at 30 mph or 60 miles at 80 mph. Perfect!

At only 6' long and 3' 6" wide, it would be possible to design a fuselage in which the car loaded up a ramp from the side, which would help the CG variation with and without load. The cost is a bit steep at about $16,000, but it would certainly be possible to take a moped like the Honda Ruckus and make an enclosed, homebuilt two-seater along the same lines. With a 49cc gas engine and three wheels, it would still be considered a scooter in most places, though you might be required to wear a helmet. The interesting thing for me about such light vehicles for getting to and from the airfield is the possibility doing this kind of cargo/car combination even within LSA regs. Let's do the math--pilot and passenger 360 lbs, enclosed scooter 200 lbs, baggage 40 lbs, 100 lbs (16 gals) fuel, that makes 700 lbs, so we'd need an empty weight of just 620 lbs--challenging but doable in a very Spartan design. Without the little car there would be 200 lbs available for camping equipment and enough space to sleep inside the fuselage. It would be an LSA equivalent of Dean Wilson's Private Explorer. Last edited: Mar 16, 2013 18. Mar 17, 2013 ### freerangequark ### freerangequark #### Well-Known Member Joined: May 24, 2012 Messages: 66 Likes Received: 12 Location: Buffalo Grove Matthew, I'm the one making the motorcycle pods so I certainly like your line of thought. Most production airplanes have 4 seats and there are rarely more than two people on board. For a majority of flights, it is possible to carry two people, a street-legal motorcycle and a bit of luggage. There are a lot of opportunities for improvement if the airplane is designed from scratch to carry the motorcycle. I've done some preliminary design work with this but I'm struggling with the business model... spending$100+ million to develop and certify a particularly specialized airplane. I think it is a safer investment to design airplanes that can haul all sorts of bulky cargo, including motorcycles. For the moment, my business is focused on solutions for existing airplanes.

Last edited by a moderator: Mar 20, 2019
19. Mar 17, 2013

### cluttonfred

#### Well-Known Member

Joined:
Feb 13, 2010
Messages:
6,351
2,208
Location:
World traveler
Nice to hear from you. Yes, I have seen your pod and it certainly seems like a novel solution, but I am more interested what could be done if starting from scratch to find the combination of aircraft and ground vehicle that together make the most sense. As I mentioned above, keeping the ground transportation down around 200 lbs opens up the possibility of using this concept even at LSA weights. I am sure you've done a lot of research on this kind of thing and I wonder what you would suggest among the lightest possible two-seaters?

Quite honestly, even the ability to take a couple of full-size mountain bikes or perhaps electrically-boosted bikes and be able to load and unload them quickly and easily might do the trick in many cases. I can imagine, for example, an LSA configured like the old Boeing YL-15 liaison plane but with side-by-side seating and the rear of the "pod" used to carry bikes, luggage, even camping gear.

20. Mar 18, 2013

Joined:
Jan 3, 2004
Messages:
139