A weighty question: What kind of scales should I use?

Discussion in 'General Experimental Aviation Questions' started by bifft, Apr 18, 2017.

Help Support HomeBuiltAirplanes Forum by donating:

1. Apr 18, 2017

bifft

Well-Known Member

Joined:
Apr 17, 2011
Messages:
205
75
Location:
Utah
Getting to be time to weigh my RV. Looking up similarly equipped ones I expect a total weight of 1050-1150lbs or so. Should be fairly evenly distributed on all three wheels or 350-400lbs. Asking around for other builders, they don't have scales in this range. Asked the local FBO, they are set up to weigh jets from the jackpoints, and don't have wheel scales. So, need to buy something. Figure I can get one scale and then build blocks for the other wheels. Jack up and weigh one wheel at a time.

I see three options:

Bridge two bathroom scales (the ones I have only go up to 300lbs). Don't need to buy anything new, but accuracy is questionable. Have one that is at least repeatable, precision is 0.2kg. Another that is +/- 1kg weighing 250lbs of me if I stop off it and walk around the room. Another I haven't used as much, but prevision is 0.5kg. (all are metric only, but that math is easy).

Buy a postal scale with 400+ range. Something like this: https://www.amazon.com/Accuteck-Digital-Industry-Shipping-ACB440/dp/B00LPUZP1I
Cheap, plenty of precision. Accuracy is unknown. Amazon reviews are mixed.

Buy a real certified aircraft scale. This seems to be the cheapest option: http://www.aircraftspruce.com/catalog/topages/scales4planes-std.php
Goes to 2klbs, way more than I need. Precision is either 1lb or 0.5lb (it says both) either is less than 0.1% of total weight, so probably Ok. Certified accurate for a year, can be recalibrated (but where would I get calibrated weights?)

I am by nature a total cheapskate, but weight and balance is a critical safety item. Thought I'd run it by the cheapskates here to see what people think.

2. Apr 18, 2017

TFF

Well-Known Member

Joined:
Apr 28, 2010
Messages:
11,119
3,012
Location:
Memphis, TN
First try to borrow some real airplane scales. Next rent some from a shop. There is a pivot bar for bathroom scales for higher weights that some use.

3. Apr 18, 2017

Well-Known Member

Joined:
Dec 9, 2004
Messages:
388
151
Location:
Hamilton New Zealand
You could try hiring a set of auto motive scales (they normally work with just three pads connected), should be able to get a set with a calibration certificate. It is better to weight all three points at the same time.

Are you sure about it being a even split across the three wells

BoKu likes this.
4. Apr 18, 2017

cdlwingnut

Well-Known MemberHBA Supporter

Joined:
May 25, 2015
Messages:
405
604
Location:
Iowa
check with the local EAA chapter, and FBOs you may be able to borrow or rent cheaply a set.

BoKu and BJC like this.
5. Apr 18, 2017

Winginit

Well-Known Member

Joined:
Jun 13, 2016
Messages:
811
242
Location:
x
akwrencher likes this.
6. Apr 18, 2017

Little Scrapper

Well-Known MemberHBA Supporter

Joined:
Jan 3, 2014
Messages:
5,239
3,145
Location:
Wisconsin
How about the RV forum? There's RV's being built everywhere, there's gotta be a bunch in Utah I'd imagine.

I think I know a guy in Utah that has scales. Where abouts are you?

7. Apr 19, 2017

lr27

Well-Known Member

Joined:
Nov 3, 2007
Messages:
3,216
463
Do you need this all the time, or just once? Around here, it appears there are many places you can rent scales of various kinds.

There's probably a simple trick you can do that avoids using commercially made scales at all. Long i-beam, pivot, and sand bags?

People used to take model airplanes down to the Post Office and weigh them. If they have 3 scales like the one in your first post, maybe you could do the same? Pick a slow day. ;-)

8. Apr 19, 2017

bifft

Well-Known Member

Joined:
Apr 17, 2011
Messages:
205
75
Location:
Utah
I'm in Provo. I've asked around, but no one in my (admittedly small) circle has any.

I got the roughly even between all wheels based on calculations from all the RV-8A wgt&balance numbers I could find posted on-line. Probably should ask on the RV forum as well. Bunch of RV's in Utah, but nobody I know well enough to ask.

9. Apr 19, 2017

Winginit

Well-Known Member

Joined:
Jun 13, 2016
Messages:
811
242
Location:
x
For the time involved in borrowing and returning them and possibly needing them more than once, it's better to have your own. Then you can make more friends by lending to them.It also allows you the option of weighing any future additions beforehand.

10. Apr 19, 2017

Little Scrapper

Well-Known MemberHBA Supporter

Joined:
Jan 3, 2014
Messages:
5,239
3,145
Location:
Wisconsin
I think there's a set 45 minutes from you. Working on it, hang tight for day.

11. Apr 19, 2017

Little Scrapper

Well-Known MemberHBA Supporter

Joined:
Jan 3, 2014
Messages:
5,239
3,145
Location:
Wisconsin

12. Apr 19, 2017

Well-Known Member

Joined:
Jul 5, 2014
Messages:
266
150
Location:
Australia
Like passengers?

I dare you to weigh your wife before each flight - tell her it's for weight and balance calcs.

Winginit and akwrencher like this.
13. Apr 19, 2017

Winginit

Well-Known Member

Joined:
Jun 13, 2016
Messages:
811
242
Location:
x
The local club I was in used to offer cheap introductory flights. One day this guy weighing well over 300 lbs came in and wanted a flight. The airport owner took one look at him and told him, "NO".

(Note: 1700 ft grass strip with electric wires at one end and trees at the other)

Last edited: Apr 19, 2017
14. Apr 19, 2017

Winginit

Joined:
Jun 13, 2016
Messages:
811
242
Location:
x
Its good to see members try to help one another, but think about how much time is going to be invested, not to mention gasoline. 3 hrs driving time and 8-10 gallons=$20+ Like I said, its great to see HBAers try to help one another, but I'd rather just put that time and money into buying a scale. 15. Apr 19, 2017 TFF TFF Well-Known Member Joined: Apr 28, 2010 Messages: 11,119 Likes Received: 3,012 Location: Memphis, TN Thats why you will buy a set of$1000 scales, for one usage, but not ever use them to weigh your plane cause its not done.

16. Apr 19, 2017

Winginit

Joined:
Jun 13, 2016
Messages:
811
242
Location:
x
The scales I recommended above were $65. And actually I have used different scales that I own to weigh many components and make decisions/choices on how to proceed with my airplane. I would think that most builders would find it beneficial to weigh many things other than just the final weight and balance of their airplane. Also, when doing weight and balance, multiple checks may need to be done if some components need relocation to achieve the best condition. making those modifications may require days and even weeks to complete properly. Don't really know why you wanted to take a cheap shot like that. Hopefully that made you feel better somehow. 17. Apr 19, 2017 Arthur Brown Arthur Brown Well-Known Member Joined: May 1, 2016 Messages: 138 Likes Received: 15 Location: London I'd expect a tail wheel load to be 10 - 15% of gross weight, or a nose wheel load to be about 20 - 30% of gross weight. I wouldn't assume three wheels taking equal loads. Three bathroom scales is the cheapest, use a lever arm made from a scaf plank or the like in a divide by three (or four) arrangement. 1200lbs split between two main wheels is 600lbs divide by 3 gives a scale reading of 200lbs a common (UK) 20 stone scale would take and read 280 lbs, so all seems OK Always it's cost vs availability 18. Apr 20, 2017 deskpilot deskpilot Well-Known Member Joined: Jun 30, 2009 Messages: 1,081 Likes Received: 180 Location: Morphett Vale, South Australia. Just south of Adel Probably a dumb question but why the need for 3 scales. Surly, the weight on each wheel will be the same whether its sitting on the ground or a couple of inches higher on a scale. Add all 3 weights together and you've got the weight of the aircraft...No? 19. Apr 20, 2017 Little Scrapper Little Scrapper Well-Known MemberHBA Supporter Joined: Jan 3, 2014 Messages: 5,239 Likes Received: 3,145 Location: Wisconsin He wasn't taking a cheap shot, come on now. I don't trust$65 scales, but that's me. I know people do use them and they have good luck I hear. That's cool.

It's very common to group buy some scales, well, at one time it was. If he spent $70,000 on a RV I'm not sure an extra$100 matters. Most EAA members know people with scales.

I drive 45 minutes to movie theatre, which incidentally is more expensive than the scales. Haha.

Battson likes this.
20. Apr 20, 2017

Joined:
Nov 3, 2007
Messages:
3,216